Navigation » List of Schools, Subjects, and Courses » English 104 – Argumentation and Critical Thinking » Discussion » Discussion of Dylan, Menkedick & James – Dylan 1 » Discussion of Dylan, Menkedick & James – Dylan 1 Sample Answers
Review the following discussion questions. Then, post a reply (200 words minimum ) to the following questions:
Do you respect Dylan’s reasons for the “experiment”, or do you believe she had other motives? Should women have the right to control their bodies, or is this action unacceptable, even in light of the #metoo movement? Do you agree with James’ assessment of feminism? How might Menkedick respond to James’ argument? How would James respond to Menkedick’s assertion that women “should not listen?” In light of the viewpoints of these 3 essays, consider: On a first date, should the man pay? If the man did not offer to pay the check, would a woman think less of him? On that first date, if the woman insisted on paying the whole check, should the man allow her? Why or why not?
After posting, respond (minimum 150 words) to at least TWO posts by your classmates.
Then reply to one of your responders (75 words minimum).
I respect Dylan’s reasons for the “experiment” but I don’t believe that it is an experiment because no one woman will try to do that type of experiment by knowing that it is bringing shame to her, her family and even there can be a risk and she never will get married. Women should have the right to control their bodies but in my opinion, they should use it in right and legal ways. I absolutely agree with