Navigation » List of Schools, Subjects, and Courses » English 104 – Argumentation and Critical Thinking » Discussion » Discussion of Essays: Caplan, Gibson, Lipson & Reindle – Caplan 1 » Discussion of Essays: Caplan, Gibson, Lipson & Reindle – Caplan 1 Sample Answers
In what respect is the challenge that students face incorporating research into their essays (Lipson & Reindle) similar to the copyright issues that Caplan & Gibson discuss in their essays? In your own experience, how is this use of property similar or different? In failing to cite sources properly, do students run the risk of appropriating property? Do you subscribe to Caplan’s belief that all ideas should be in public domain? Therefore, should citation in student research papers be eliminated? Is it appropriate for people to claim their ideas as “property”? You can discuss any issues you have had with citing in prior papers.
Post a discussion response (200 words minimum) that addresses the question above. Due by Friday 14 January.
Post a reply to at least TWO responses to posts by peers (each 150 words minimum) that furthers their discussion. Due by Saturday 15 January.
Post a reply back to at least one peer. Due by Saturday 15 January.
The challenge that students face in incorporating research into their essays is that, sometimes, for misunderstanding, they can be accused of plagiarism. According to Lipson and Reindle’s essay, they explain, “We are resonating to the same events, the same realities in our environment, rather than to one another’s words or observations” (11). The authors explain how they work in their articles and in their essays, they mention how